Solve Circle Equation x²-10ax+y²-4yb=-20ab with Parameter Conditions

Question

x210ax+y24yb=20ab x^2-10ax+y^2-4yb=-20ab

The above equation represents a circle

If the parameters are

a,b a,\hspace{2pt}b

then the solution depends on the following:

y=x y=x

Step-by-Step Solution

Let's recall first that the equation of a circle with center at point:

O(xo,yo) O(x_o,y_o)

and its radiusR R is:

(xxo)2+(yyo)2=R2 (x-x_o)^2+(y-y_o)^2=R^2

Let's now return to the problem and the given circle equation and examine it:

x210ax+y24yb=20ab x^2-10ax+y^2-4yb=-20ab

We can extract from it the circle's center and its (square) radius,

We'll do this using "completing the square":

x210ax+y24yb=20abx22x5a+y22y2b=20ab(x5a)2(5a)2+(y2b)2(2b)2=20ab(x5a)2+(y2b)2=(5a)220ab+(2b)2O(5a,2b),RO2=(5a)220ab+(2b)2 x^2-10ax+y^2-4yb=-20ab \\ \downarrow\\ x^2-2\cdot x\cdot \textcolor{blue}{5a}+y^2-2\cdot y\cdot \textcolor{red}{2b}=-20ab \\ \downarrow\\ (x-\textcolor{blue}{5a})^2-(\textcolor{blue}{5a})^2+(y-\textcolor{red}{2b})^2-(\textcolor{red}{2b})^2=-20ab\\ (x-5a)^2+(y-2b)^2=(5a)^2-20ab+(2b)^2\\ \rightarrow\boxed{O(5a,2b),\hspace{4pt}R_O^2=(5a)^2-20ab+(2b)^2}

Note that for the circle's radius squared we got an algebraic expression that includes both parameters from the problem,

Note additionally that this expression can be factored into a squared binomial (using the perfect square formula):

RO2=(5a)220ab+(2b)2RO2=(5a)225a2b+(2b)2RO2=(5a2b)2 R_O^2=(5a)^2-20ab+(2b)^2 \\ \downarrow\\ R_O^2=(5a)^2-2\cdot5a\cdot2b+(2b)^2\\ \boxed{ R_O^2=(5a-2b)^2}

To summarize, we found that the center of the given circle represented by the equation and its radius (squared) are:

O(5a,2b),RO2=(5a2b)2 \rightarrow\boxed{O(5a,2b),\hspace{4pt}R_O^2=(5a-2b)^2}

Now let's note that there is a constraint on the parameters in the problem, let's look at the radius squared expression: RO2 R_O^2 ,

and note that although this expression: (5a2b)2 (5a-2b)^2 must be non-negative (since it's an expression that is squared) meaning there's no contradiction with the fact that it equals the radius squared,

still- it could be zero, which would contradict the initial given- stating that the given equation represents a circle equation, (and therefore it's impossible that the radius derived from it would be zero),

meaning we must require that:

RO05a2b05a2b R_O\neq0\\ \downarrow\\ 5a-2b\neq0\\ \downarrow\\ \boxed{5a\neq2b}

Let's return now to the expression for the circle's center that we got and note that we can conclude from the constraint we found on the parameters that:

O(xo,yo)O(5a,2b)5a2bxoyo O(x_o,y_o)\leftrightarrow O(5a,2b)\leftrightarrow 5a\neq2b\\ \downarrow\\ \boxed{x_o\neq y_o}

meaning- it's impossible for the circle's center point to have identical x and y coordinates!

However- if we assume that the circle's center point indeed lies on the line: y=x y=x then it must satisfy it, meaning it must be true that:

yo=xo \textcolor{red}{\boxed{y_o=x_o}}

But of course as mentioned before this is a contradiction to the constraint we found earlier(!!)

(which came from requiring that the circle's radius cannot be zero)

Therefore we conclude that there are no parametersa,b a,\hspace{2pt}b for which the circle's center (represented by the given equation) lies on the line: y=x y=x .

Therefore- the correct answer is answer C.

Answer

a,b a,\hspace{2pt}b do not exist